Baked to Remember. Indulgence in Every Bite.

From Dainty Beginnings to a Stuffed Obsession!

Our dessert journey began back in 2008, handcrafting sweet treats that blended comfort, culture, and creativity. What started as a passion project quickly turned into something more — a love for desserts that felt nostalgic, tasted luxurious, and brought people together.

By 2016, we narrowed our focus to what had truly captured hearts (and spoons): our signature small-batch pudding jars. Under the name Dainty Puddings, we shipped creamy layers of joy nationwide — each jar a hug in dessert form.

But we were never meant to stop at pudding.

That same creative spark has led us into a new era of indulgence — one where the love of stuffed, swirled, and flavor-forward desserts takes center stage.

A Stuffed Affair was born to celebrate our roots while expanding the table.

Today, we still offer our beloved puddings — don’t worry, they’re going nowhere. But now, we’re also serving up:

Gooey oatmeal cream pies

Layered dessert bars

And a growing menu of handcrafted, cream-filled creations that change with the seasons and your cravings.

 

At our core, we’re the same brand you fell in love with:

Southern soul. Caribbean heart. Cream in every corner.

Textures that melt, crunch, and surprise.

A little cheeky. A lot nostalgic. Always unforgettable.

 

But we believe dessert should do more than taste good — it should do good.

A portion of every purchase supports We Are Tough Cookies Inc., our nonprofit dedicated to uplifting neurodivergent families and caregivers of micro-preemies. Through grants, support, and advocacy, we’re using our platform to pour back into the community that inspires us every day.

So when you indulge with us, you’re not just treating yourself —

you’re joining a mission stuffed with meaning.

Baked to Remember. Indulgence in Every Bite.

Welcome to A Stuffed Affair.

We're so glad you're part of the story.

A love letter to stuffed desserts.

 

Miss Stuffins